By: ULFAT AZIZ-US-SAMAD


Inside Cover
Copy Rights
PREFACE
INTRODUCTION
THE GOSPELS AND THE QURAN
Composition & Character of the Gospels
The Unreliability of the Gospels
The Authenticity of the Quran
JESUS AND MUHAMMAD
The Life and Mission of Jesus Christ
The Prophet Muhammad
The Ideal Character
Historicity
Complete Model
THE DOCTRINES OF ISLAM AND CHRISTIANITY
The Trinity
The Divinity of Jesus
The Divine Sonship
The Original Sin
God's Justice.
The Blood Atonement.
Islam: A Rational Religion
THE MORAL TEACHIN GS OF ISLAM AND CHRISTIANITY
Non-resistance to Evil
Monasticism and Celibacy
Wine, Sex, Gambling
ISLAM: A UNIVERSAL RELIGION
The Status of Women in Islam and Christianity
Elimination of Slavery
Political Constitution
The Economics of Islam
Religious Freedom
The Universal Brotherhood of Islam

Islambasics Library: Islam & Christianty

The Unreliability of the Gospels

 

The Gospels were composed after the early Christians had become divided into different factions. They were in fact composed to propagate the special teachings of the various schools. Thus, their authors showed no hesitation in tampering with the earlier documents and other traditional materials regarding the life and teaching of Jesus to bring them in line with the views of their schools. Rev. T. G. Tucker states:

 

"Thus Gospels were produced which clearly reflected the conception of the practical needs of the community for which they were written. In them the traditional material was used, but these was no hesitation in altering it or making additions to it, or in leaving out what did not suit the writer's purpose".[1]

 

The four Gospels included in the Bible were not the only Gospels written in the early centuries of Christianity. There were many others, including the one called "The Gospels according to the Hebrews", an Aramaic work which was used by the Nazarenes (as the early disciples of Jesus were called), who denied the divinity of Jesus and regarded him only as a great prophet. Towards the end of the second century the Gospels of Mark, Matthew, Luke and John were included in the Canon and the rest were declared to be heretical or apocryphal by the Church. Before they were canonized and accepted as scriptures, the Gospels did not have that sanctity which they have now and no one felt any compunction in altering them if anything contained in them did not suit his purpose or the purpose of his sect. Even after they were included in the Canon and declared to be the Word of God, changes continued to be made in them, as is clear from the different early extant manuscripts. Referring to this, Professor Dummelow from Cambridge writes in his famous Commentary on the Holy Bible:

 

"A copyist would sometimes put in not what was in the text, but what he thought ought to be in it. He would trust a fickle memory, or he would make the text accord with views of the school to which he belonged. In addition to the versions and quotations from the Christian Fathers, nearly four thousand Greek MSS of the Testament, were known to exist. As a result the variety of reading is considerable."[2]

 

In considering how far the four Canonical Gospels faithfully present the inspired message or Gospel of Jesus we must bear the following facts in mind: (1) that no written copy was made

of the inspired sayings of Jesus in his life time; (2) that the earliest records of the sayings of Jesus, which were made shortly after his departure, when the glorification of Jesus had already begun, have all been irretrievably lost; (3) that in the Gospels, which were written between 70 and 115 C. E. on the basis of some lost documents, the material contained in them was handled rather freely; the Gospel-writers felt no hesitation in changing it for what they considered to be the greater glory of Christ or to bring it in line with the views of their sects; (4) that none of the Evangelists had known Jesus or heard him speaking; (5) that the Gospels were written in Greek, whereas the language spoken by Jesus was Aramaic;(6) that they were composed to

propagate the points of view of the different factions and chosen from many others which represented different view-points, (7) that for at least a century after they were written they had no canonical authority and were actually changed by the copyists of the different sects to serve their own purpose; (8) that the earliest extant manuscripts of the Gospels - Codex Sinaiticus, Codex Vaticanus, and Codex Alexandrinus - belong to the fourth and fifth centuries, and no one knows to what extent the Gospels had been changed during the centuries of which no manuscript is available; (9) that there are considerable differences at many places among the various extant manuscripts of the fourth and fifth centuries; and (10) that the Gospels, taken as a whole, are full of contradictions.

 

These facts disclosed by distinguished Western scholars go to show that the Gospel of Jesus, by which we mean the Message which Jesus had received from God, has not reached us in its original form. The four Gospels included in the Bible cannot be considered identical with the inspired Gospel of Jesus. The manner of their composition and the circumstances through which they have passed are such that they cannot be relied upon to give us the exact knowledge of what Jesus had said and ~ taught. C. J. Cadoux sums up the position in these words in his book Life of Jesus.

 

"In the four Gospels, therefore, the main documents to which we must go if we are to fill-out at all that bare sketch which we can put together from other sources, we find material of widely differing quality as regards credibility. So far-reaching is the element of uncertainty that it is tempting to 'down tools' at once, and to declare the task hopeless. The historical inconsistencies and improbabilities in parts of the Gospels form some of arguments advanced in favour of the Christ-myth theory. These are, however, entirely outweighed - as we have shown - by other considerations. Still, the discrepancies and uncertainties that remain are serious and

consequently many modems, who have no doubt whatever of Jesus' real existence, regard as hopeless any attempt to dissolve out the historically-true from the legendary or mythical matter which the Gospels contain, and to reconstruct the story of ]esus' mission out of the more historical residue."[3]

 



[1] T.G. Tuncker: The History cj the Christians in the Light of Modern Knowledge, p.320.

 

[2] J.R. Dummelow: Commentary on the Holy Bible, p.l6.

 

[3] C. J. Cadoux: op. cit., pp. 16,17.

 


misconceptions about islam , Misconceptions On Human Rights In Islam , Muhamed no 1 , Muhammad the Greatest , MUHAMMAD'S PROPHETHOOD , Muhummed The Natural Successor To Christ , Muslim character , Muslim guide to Jehovah s witness , Muslim Response To Christian Response , Muslim-Christian Dialogue , My Dear Beloved Son or Daughter , night prayers during Ramadan , nullifiers of Islam , OH! YOU!! HINDU AWAKE! , On Cosmic Verses in The Quran , order in Islam , OUR MESSAGE , Peace from an Islamic standpoint , PEACE IN ISLAM , PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT IN ISLAM , PILGRIMAGE ORGANIZING INSTRUCTIONS , Pitfalls in the Quest for Knowledge , Polygyny: The wisdom of love , prayer and Ramadan , Prayer in Congregation , Principles of Islamic Faith (Al-`Aqidah Al-Wasitiyah) , Priorities of The Islamic Movement in The Coming Phase , PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS , Prohibitions that are taken too lightly , Proof of The Preservation of the Quran , PROPHET MUHAMMAD - THE INFINITE LIGHT , PROPHET OF ISLAM  MUHAMMED and  SOME OF HIS TRADITIONS , prophets stories , purpose of life , quran dictionary , Religion Of Islam , respond to the call of the prayer , Resurrection or Resuscitation , Rulings on divorce and connected matters in the Qur aan , ryad elsaleheen , SACRIFICE - The Making of a Muslim , Sahih Bukhari , Sahih Muslim , SALMAN THE PERSIAN , SCIENCE EDUCATION AND RELIGIOUS VALUES , seventy ways to earn reward , SHARI'AH - THE WAY TO GOD , shytan his ways of misleading , Social Laws in Islam , SOURCE METHODOLOGY IN ISLAMIC JURISPRUDENCE: , SPOTLIGHTS ON ISLAM , ST PAUL , status of women , Stories of new Muslims , stories of the prophets , STUDIES IN ISLAM SERIES ISLAM AND CONTEMPORARY ECONOMIC THEORIES , Supplication and its manners, times, conditions, mistakes , Tafseer Ayat Al-Kursi , Tafsir of surat alfatiha , The 2 Eids , The Abridgments of the prophet's prayer , The Amazing Quran , The Aqeedah of the Pious Predecessors , The Arab's Impact on European Civilization , The Authentic Creed And the Invalidators of Islam , The basis of Muslim belief , The beard , The book of knowledge , The Buddhas of Bamyan , The Call For The Unity Of Religions: true of false , The Causes Responsible for Materialist Tendencies in the West , THE CHALLENGE OF ISLAM , The Character of the Companions , The compilation of hadith , THE CONSEQUENCE OF ATTRIBUTING LINEAGES TO A MAN WHO HAD NO LINEAGE , The Creed of Al-Bukhari , The creed of the sahabah , The Criterion , The DAY of WRATH , The Declaration of Faith , The Difference between Advising and Condemning , The Essence of Economic Policy in Importance of Islamic Economics , The Establishment of Proof , THE ETERNAL MESSAGE OF MUHAMMAD , The Ethics of Disagreement in Islam , THE ETIIQUETTES OF MARRIIAGE AND WEDDIING , The evil consequences of adultery , The Evil of Smoking  , The Face Veil , THE FINALITY OF PROPHETHOOD , The fiqh of hajj for women , The Foundations of the Islamic Belief , The fundamentals of Islam , The Glorious Quran English Translation , The God That Never Was , The Good End , The Hardening of the Heart , The ideal Muslim , The ideal muslimah , THE IDEOLOGICAL ATTACK , The Importance of Straightening the Ranks in Prayer  , The Islamic Call , THE JUSTICE OF GOD, HIS MERCY, PROMISE AND THREAT , The Last Sermon Of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH , The Lawful and Prohibited in Islam , The Life of Muhammad , The life of this world , The Light of the Prophet , The Magnifying Glass On Clarifying Many Common Errors , The manners of a scholar and student of knowledge , The Many Dangers of the Tongue , The Meaning of Our Testimony that Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the Messenger of Allah ,